← All brews

21B Black IPA

Black IPA (June 2022)

Brewed 2022-06-23 Batch · 20.8 L Owen Paterson

Grain bill

Gladfield Ale Malt 6 kg 85.7%
Gladfield Medium Crystal Malt 0.35 kg 5%
Gladfield Munich Malt 0.35 kg 5%
Gladfield Dark Chocolate Malt 0.3 kg 4.3%

Adjuncts

Whirlfloc half tablet @ 15 min
Yeast nutrient half tsp @ 15 min

Hop schedule

Hop 60 minWPDH#1
Simcoe 20g60g70g
Riwaka ·30g70g
Mosaic ·70g30g

Yeast

Safale US-052 packets

Water additions

Calcium Sulphate 1 tsp in mash
Calcium Chloride half tsp in mash
Lactic acid (88%) half tsp in sparge water, target pH 5.5

Tasting notes

Less fizzy and head after 2 weeks bottle conditioning than the May 2022 Black IPA (batch 24). The 105 g priming sugar (vs 120 g in batch 24) appears to have under-carbonated this batch. Future iterations should sit back at 120–130 g.

About This Beer

Second captured Black IPA — a direct yeast A/B vs the May 2022 Black IPA (batch 24). Same grain bill, same hop schedule, same step mash, same water profile, brewed seven weeks later. The only deliberate change: Safale US-05 in place of MJ M44 US West Coast.

What’s Identical to Batch 24

  • Grain bill — 7.0 kg total (6.0 kg Gladfield Ale, 0.35 kg Medium Crystal, 0.35 kg Munich, 0.30 kg Dark Chocolate)
  • Hop bill — 350 g across Simcoe / Riwaka / Mosaic at the same timings
  • Step mash — 50 °C protein rest, 68 °C saccharification, 75 °C mash out
  • Water profile — 1 tsp CaSO₄ + ½ tsp CaCl₂ in mash; sparge pH 5.5 with lactic acid
  • 60-minute boil

What Changed

  1. Yeast — Safale US-05 (2 packets) instead of MJ M44 US West Coast (2 packets)
  2. Bottling sugar — 105 g (down from 120 g in batch 24)

The Yeast Comparison

Batch 24 (M44)Batch 25 (US-05)
OG1.0621.052
FG1.0101.013
Attenuation83.9 %75.0 %
ABV6.83 %6.43 %

The OG missed by 10 points this time (vs 9 in batch 24) — combined with batch 24’s miss on the same recipe, this points to the step mash being the consistent extraction limiter. US-05 attenuated less hard here despite often outperforming M44 elsewhere — but with a different starting OG it’s not a clean A/B.

The qualitative yeast difference in the finished beer isn’t captured in the tasting note — only the carbonation feedback.

Hop Reuse

The notebook records “$74 (plus 100 g hops from last)” — Owen carried 100 g of hops over from batch 24’s leftovers. Cash spend $74 + carryover value ≈ $88.81 total ($4.27/L).

Fermentation

2 packets of Safale US-05 pitched at 20 °C. Dry hop on day 5 from pitch: 70 g Simcoe + 70 g Riwaka + 30 g Mosaic.

Packaging — Priming Sugar Reduced

105 g of castor sugar for bottle conditioning — down from 120 g in batch 24. At 20.8 L bottled that’s ~5.0 g/L, below the typical 5.5–6.5 g/L range.

Tasting confirmed it was too low: “less fizzy and head after 2 weeks bottle conditioning than #24”.

Owen had been reducing priming sugar progressively — 150 g (earlier batches) → 130 g (Hazy IPA II) → 120 g (batch 24) → 105 g (this batch). Each previous reduction had been acceptable, but the step from 120 → 105 over-shot the line. The takeaway: sit back at 120–130 g for this recipe.

Numbers

StageTargetActual
Mash + sparge34 L34 L
Pre-boil28 L27.5 L
Boil addition2 L2.5 L
Post-boil26 L26 L
Into fermenter23.5 L23 L
Bottle22 L20.8 L
TargetActual
OG1.0621.052
FG1.0101.013
ABV6.83 %6.43 %

Targets set from batch 24’s actuals — Owen aiming for a repeatable result.

Cost

Line itemAmount
Cash spend (new ingredients)$74
Carryover hops (100 g from batch 24)~$15 (imputed)
Total~$88.81
Per litre (at 20.8 L)$4.27

Lineage